Estimated read time: 2-3 minutes
This archived news story is available only for your personal, non-commercial use. Information in the story may be outdated or superseded by additional information. Reading or replaying the story in its archived form does not constitute a republication of the story.
SALT LAKE COUNTY -- Salt Lake County Sheriff Jim Winder says the jail is changing some policies and re-evaluating all of them following the starvation death of an inmate earlier this year.
Carlos Umana died at a weight below 80 pounds on Feb. 27 after spending four months in the county jail. He weighed more than double that when he was first booked.
It is highly problematic to have an individual starve to death inside a correctional facility and if I have my way it'll never happen again.
–Salt Lake County Sheriff Jim Winder
"We're definitely taking this situation very seriously," Winder said. "We are evaluating all of our processes and have made some short-term alterations to ensure that it doesn't happen."
Winder said the jail was aware of Umana's mental health issues and at the time of his death workers were evaluating how to address his not eating. He could not further disclose terms of Umana's condition.
Winder called the death "unexpected," and said Umana had interacted with guards just 15 to 20 minutes prior to his passing. He said if jail officials felt there was an imminent risk of death, they would have intervened sooner.
"He was being monitored, he was being assessed," Winder said. "Could those assessments have been expedited? Those are all questions we're dealing with, but by golly we don't let people just lay in on gurneys and die in here."
Winder acknowledged Wednesday the jail could do a better job.
"It is highly problematic to have an individual starve to death inside a correctional facility and if I have my way it'll never happen again," Winder said.
Winder said a more recent case has surfaced with another inmate not eating. He said the jail is evaluating the man's nutritional needs. The jail security, medical and mental health staffs all look at these situations, Winder said.
Winder said inmates do have the right to not eat and intervention becomes a difficult "philosophical, legal and moral" decision.
"It's a tragedy -- there's no other way to say this," Winder said. "To have an individual come into a correctional facility and go out at 78 pounds is a tragedy. Period."
Umana was in jail on a first-degree felony attempted murder charge after he allegedly stabbed his mother's boyfriend in October 2010. He was 20 years old.
Email:aadams@ksl.com
