Estimated read time: 3-4 minutes
This archived news story is available only for your personal, non-commercial use. Information in the story may be outdated or superseded by additional information. Reading or replaying the story in its archived form does not constitute a republication of the story.
SALT LAKE CITY — The Utah Rivers Council unveiled its ambitious 4200 Project — a year in the works — that includes 12 recommendations including drastic measures, such as restructuring water rates and banning ornamental grass altogether in Utah.
"There is no goal to restore the (Great Salt Lake) by Utah and that is really a problem," said Zach Frankel, executive director of the council. "Gov. (Spencer) Cox has been reluctant to support a water elevation goal and that has allowed him to celebrate minor successes."
Frankel said the lake needs an additional 8 million acre-feet of water and to get there, even if every northern Utah farmer stopped using water and every man, woman and child in northern Utah didn't use any water, it would still take 4½ years to get there.
"(This is) to give a sense of scale of how big this expedition is that we are on. We are not climbing the foothills. We are climbing Mount Everest or Mount K and we need to be realistic and honest with ourselves," Frankel said.
The council, among its most ambitious goals, aims to stop all upstream diversions to the Great Salt Lake not only in Utah, but the neighboring states of Idaho and Wyoming that are part of the Bear River Compact.
"We need to work with the community of farmers in Wyoming and Idaho to purchase their water where we can and invest in efficiency measures, but make sure that the water saved through efficiency measures on farms is actually delivered to the Great Salt Lake and not like we 'oh, we need to do that someday,' which is the current policy in Utah," Frankel said.
"So that means we need to start working with Idaho and Wyoming and, for that matter, federal funding sources so we can start to work together to transfer surplus and wasted water on the farms of Idaho, Wyoming and Utah to deliver to the Great Salt Lake."
The council's dozen legislative recommendations include:
- Overhaul the "broken" state agricultural optimization program to make sure all the water saved gets to the Great Salt Lake.
- Quit subsidizing water rates through property taxes so the true cost of water is reflected.
- Create a mechanism by which water rights are permanently secured for the benefit of the Great Salt Lake and not just leased.
- Require a strict accounting for all secondary water use.
The council's 140-plus page report takes a deep dive into what it says has been a systemic mismanagement of a vital ecosystem not only important to Utah but to all residents of the United States and beyond.
The Great Salt Lake is the largest remaining wetland ecosystem in the American West, supporting 330 migratory bird species totaling eight to 10 million birds that travel from every country in South and Central America. Many birds gather at the Great Salt Lake in larger numbers than anywhere else on the planet, according to the council, landing the lake as a key resting place on the Pacific Flyway.
Frankel contends the state's agricultural optimization program, in which $200 million of new money was directed last year, is a failed effort because it does not guarantee any of the water that is "saved" makes it to the Great Salt Lake.
"There's been descriptions that it's actually going to lead to Great Salt Lake water deliveries. In actuality, there's nothing in that statute that requires saved water on these farms to be delivered to the Great Salt Lake. There's been a lot of talk about that, but there's no requirement," he said.
Frankel said leaders need to be held accountable, instead of digging through the cushions of a couch to come up with spare change to make a "house" payment on the lake. Rather, they need to come with a meaningful mortgage payment or plan to keep Utah's most critical ecosystem vibrant.
