2 Wisconsin families settle with GM over crash

2 Wisconsin families settle with GM over crash

1 photo
Save Story
Leer en español

Estimated read time: 4-5 minutes

This archived news story is available only for your personal, non-commercial use. Information in the story may be outdated or superseded by additional information. Reading or replaying the story in its archived form does not constitute a republication of the story.

DETROIT (AP) — As General Motors begins to compensate the victims of crashes tied to faulty ignition switches, this week more than a dozen families were given a choice: accept a settlement, presumably in the millions of dollars, or fight GM in a potentially lengthy court battle.

On Thursday, the families of two Wisconsin teenagers killed in an Oct. 24, 2006, crash of a Chevrolet Cobalt accepted cash offers from Kenneth Feinberg, the lawyer hired by GM to settle with victims on its behalf, according to Robert Hilliard, the families' attorney. They recently dropped a lawsuit GM in favor of seeking a settlement.

The crash that killed Natasha Weigel, who was 18, and Amy Rademaker, who was 15, was among the first blamed on the faulty switches. Despite evidence from that crash and others that the switches could cause the engine to stall and the air bags to be disabled, GM and federal regulators failed to make that connection for years.

GM finally recalled 2.6 million cars equipped with the switches early this year.

The girls' deaths are among 21 that Feinberg has deemed eligible for payments from GM. Feinberg began accepting wrongful death and injury claims on Aug. 1.

As of Wednesday, Feinberg had received 143 death claims, with the rest still being evaluated. The offers to the Wisconsin girls' families were two of 15 he made this week, his spokeswoman said.

GM has admitted that people within the company knew for years that the switches were defective yet failed to act to fix the problem. Even so, some victims' families would have a difficult time winning against the automaker in court because of the terms of GM's 2009 bankruptcy.

A bankruptcy judge ruled that GM is shielded from liability in crashes that occurred prior to July 2009. It's unclear how many small-car crash injuries or fatalities occurred prior to then. GM engineers knew of problems with the Cobalt switches as early as 2004. The first fatal crash the company learned of happened in 2005.

Amy Rademaker's mother, Margie Beskau, of Woodville, Wisconsin, said Wednesday she saw little chance of winning in court because her daughter died before GM filed for bankruptcy.

Both families accepted Feinberg's offers Thursday, Hilliard said. He would not disclose the amounts, although a day earlier he estimated the families would each be offered around $3 million, based on the formula Feinberg uses to calculate compensation.

"It is a significant offer," he said. "The offer is within the realms of reasonableness."

The Weigel family's offer was slightly higher because she lived for 11 days after the crash, Hilliard said.

The driver of the Cobalt, Megan Phillips, was also a plaintiff in the lawsuit. She survived the crash but suffered permanent brain damage.

GM has determined that the switches can unexpectedly slip into the "accessory" position, shutting off the engine and disabling key features such as power-assisted steering, and the car's air bags. The data recorder in Phillips' 2005 Cobalt showed that the ignition switch was in "accessory" at the time of the crash.

A Wisconsin state trooper investigating the crash made the connection between the position of the switch and the air bags not deploying. Investigations into the handling of the recall — one commissioned by GM, and one from a Congressional committee — found that both the company and regulators were aware of the trooper's finding but largely ignored it for years.

Families of victims of crashes that happened after July 2009 may be willing to fight in court because GM can be found liable for death or injury. For example, the family of Brooke Melton, a Georgia nurse who died in a 2010 Cobalt crash, settled last year for $5 million. But, citing what they say is new evidence that GM concealed the switch problem, the Meltons want the settlement overturned so they can seek a larger jury verdict.

Carl Tobias, a law professor at the University of Richmond in Virginia, said GM's bankruptcy shield makes going to Feinberg a better option in the case of a pre-bankruptcy crash.

For GM, Tobias said, it's advantageous to encourage settlements with Feinberg — even for millions of dollars — to avoid bad publicity, legal costs and the risk of huge verdicts. The automaker has set aside $400 million in its compensation fund and may pay out up to $600 million.

Although Beskau wants people within GM to be prosecuted, she had kind words for Feinberg. He previously handled payments to victims of the 9/11 terrorist attacks and the BP oil spill.

When the Rademaker and Weigel families told Feinberg their stories in August, "he wanted to get to know us so he could actually get a sense of who our daughters were," she said. "To him, they are not just numbers, they are people."

Hilliard said Phillips will present her case at a later date.


Forliti reported from Minneapolis.

Copyright © The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Most recent Business stories

Related topics



    Get informative articles and interesting stories delivered to your inbox weekly. Subscribe to the KSL.com Trending 5.
    By subscribing, you acknowledge and agree to KSL.com's Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

    KSL Weather Forecast