UVU calls Sharon McMahon a force for good. Critics call the choice 'tone deaf'

SALT LAKE CITY — Mixed reactions followed Utah Valley University's announcement last month that "America's Government Teacher," Sharon McMahon, would be the 2026 commencement speaker.

McMahon was criticized by conservatives for her reaction to the assassination of Charlie Kirk, and some on campus feel she wasn't the right choice to speak to the school this year.

Since news of McMahon's participation in the commencement for what will be the university's largest graduating class in its history was posted, UVU spokesperson Sharon Turner told the Deseret News, "The responses to her speaking for commencement have been overwhelmingly positive," and that McMahon previously spoke on campus and was "well-received."

"She focuses on a nonpartisan approach to history and civics, which is consistent with our standards as a university," Turner added.

As a New York Times-bestselling author, award-winning educator and podcaster, McMahon has a notable platform that focuses on political issues, both current and historical. She often makes guest appearances on news platforms and podcasts.

"Sharon McMahon is an original. She is a force of nature and a force for good. As a former history teacher, she understands that education can inform, inspire, and instigate courageous action," UVU President Astrid Tuminez said in a press release. "She underlines how each of us can contribute to a vibrant democracy and how strength comes from knowledge, kindness, and collective action."

Her website also touts her as a source for "nonpartisan insight that makes sense of the news, unpacks misinformation, and connects the dots from history to today. My goal is simple: Tell the truth, explain it clearly, and help you understand how our system works — so together, we can make it work better."

Related:

'America's government teacher' Sharon McMahon to speak at UVU commencement

An educator and author hailed as "America's government teacher" will be the commencement speaker at this year's Utah Valley University graduation ceremony.

But not all students at UVU were delighted with the news that McMahon was returning to the school, specifically because of comments she made about Kirk, the conservative activist and Turning Point USA cofounder who was killed last September on UVU's campus.

Comments on a social media post by UVU announcing McMahon's participation in commencement were mostly positive, but others found the selection "tone deaf," a decision "only good for liberals, not conservatives" and "disgraceful."

Less than a week after thousands witnessed the assassination of Kirk in the opening moments of his "American Comeback Tour" on Sept. 10, 2025, McMahon posted a thread about Kirk that she has since deleted.

The thread remained online early Wednesday, as Amber Gustafson, a former Democratic candidate for the Iowa state Senate, had reposted it. That post, however, has since been removed.

Others reposted it to rebut McMahon's claims, with one critic calling her post "vile."

UVU's Turning Point USA chapter president, Caleb Chilcutt, told the Deseret News that McMahon's now-deleted post was a "series of out-of-context quotes from Charlie in an effort to tarnish his name and minimize the tragedy, rather than offering condolences or condemning political violence."

"While universities should welcome diverse viewpoints, platforming someone who treated a historic and tragic political assassination, not as a moment to grieve, but as an opportunity to create content, is tone-deaf and disrespectful to those still affected, especially on this campus," he continued.

Related topics