News / 

`Indecision' Answers Life's Big Questions _ Or Not

Save Story
Leer en espaƱol

Estimated read time: 3-4 minutes

This archived news story is available only for your personal, non-commercial use. Information in the story may be outdated or superseded by additional information. Reading or replaying the story in its archived form does not constitute a republication of the story.

"Indecision: A Novel" by Benjamin Kunkel; Random House ($21.95)


Dwight B. Wilmerding, the 28-year-old protagonist of Benjamin Kunkel's debut novel "Indecision," may deem himself a mediocre man, an obedient dog, an overzealous thinker but an ever-tepid doer. But Kunkel himself, an editor of the literary journal "n+1," writing his first book, is none of these things.

Maybe he was, or maybe he thinks he is, an argument sure to be debated by anyone wise enough to give "Indecision" a read. Kunkel's insight into his protagonist is astoundingly authentic, with Dwight's anxieties and elations, his wit and cruelty, practically breathing through Kunkel's rich words.

Kunkel inspires chuckles and contented sighs with his absurd, youthful, occasionally poetic descriptions. His dialogues in particular are incredibly insightful and meaty, familiar yet fresh.

Despite an overdone formula - a coming-of-age yarn - Kunkel brings enough novelty to the material to emerge as an alpha author rather than a mindless mutt obeying the expectations of the genre.

He obviously has a lot on his mind that he expresses through Dwight, who addresses those big questions about meaning and purpose, happiness and responsibility. In pondering these questions, Kunkel has given birth to a new story and hero for all the Dwight B. Wilmerdings out there to embrace, along with Hamlet, Holden Caulfield and Dave Eggers' alter ego from "A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius."

Dwight has a problem. Actually, he has several problems. He's overeducated but unambitious. He's stuck in a dead-end job at a drug company. He can't commit to his girlfriend Vaneetha. He simply won't grow up. All this just scratches the surface.

Yet Dwight claims his woes primarily stem from one thing - he suffers from "abulia," the impairment or inability to make decisions. So he tests a yet-to-be released drug called Abulinix, seemingly a magic cure for all of his ailments. Soon enough, influenced by the drug or at least the very taking of the drug, Dwight abandons his job and Vaneetha, and sets off from New York City to Quito, Ecuador, in pursuit of a Dutch prep school classmate, Natasha, on whom he's had a crush for years.

Soon after he arrives, though, Natasha flies the coop, stranding Dwight in a foreign land with her Belgian/Argentine friend Brigid, herself marooned in Ecuador after abandoning her thesis for something she hasn't decided on yet. They philosophize and bicker. They explore the jungles and trip on intense drugs. Their sexual tension comes to a boil. And when Dwight returns home, he more or less finds the answers to those big questions, or at the very least doesn't let their ominous presence paralyze him any longer.

Based on Dwight's crippling anxieties, the sudden reversal of fortune seems too convenient to be believed, while a sudden plot revelation and the character's politically motivated call for action seem far-fetched and preachy, respectively.

But then Kunkel shreds the neatly wrapped package by questioning the incredible clarity and potential preposterousness of the character's revelations, and then suddenly, bitingly, ends his book on a note of indecision.

It just goes to show that the big questions can never concretely be answered and that big decisions rarely lead to pat conclusions. But their exploration is nevertheless an important part of life, especially when seen through the eyes of a good book's compelling hero.


(c) 2005, Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. Distributed by Knight Ridder/Tribune News Service.

Most recent News stories


Get informative articles and interesting stories delivered to your inbox weekly. Subscribe to the Trending 5.
By subscribing, you acknowledge and agree to's Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

KSL Weather Forecast