Doctor plans to resume canceled $1.3B National Children's Study in Utah

Doctor plans to resume canceled $1.3B National Children's Study in Utah

(Shutterstock)


Save Story

Estimated read time: 5-6 minutes

This archived news story is available only for your personal, non-commercial use. Information in the story may be outdated or superseded by additional information. Reading or replaying the story in its archived form does not constitute a republication of the story.

SALT LAKE CITY — The National Children's Study aimed to survey and learn from the country's youths, including up to 1,000 Utah families enrolled in recent years.

And though the federal government forked out more than $1.3 billion for the promising first-of-its-kind research, rising costs and an unfeasible study design left one of the largest research efforts abandoned in the 30 locations across the United States where it was set to begin.

The federal government's National Institutes of Health said at the end of December that it would no longer fund the National Children's Study, but one Utah doctor, researcher and educator vows to keep it going, at least in the state.

"The original goals of the National Children's Study to understand genetics and environment and their relationship in health and development still remain a top priority in our country," said Dr. Edward B. Clark, chairman of pediatrics at the University of Utah School of Medicine and former principal investigator for the study in Utah. "The health of our children will determine, in many ways, the future of our country."

Clark said he's in the process of contacting the Salt Lake County and Cache County families who enlisted in the study and is working on a plan to move forward, continuing to collect data that might have an impact in children's health.

"If we can't do it at a federal level, we're going to do it here in Utah," he said, adding that he expects a study that follows children from before birth to age 21 to be a big undertaking, as well as costly, but Clark is assured Utah "can do it in a more efficient way."

Biological samples, numerous questionnaires and other empirical data collected from the thousands of families nationwide lays dormant for the time being, unattached to any of the hypothetical findings the original study set out to discover.

Related Story

The National Institutes of Health, however, has made it clear that the stores of data collected during the pilot phase of the National Children's Study are available "upon request by investigators for secondary analyses," according to the agency's statement on the study's closure.

A report on the progress of several years of a pilot study concluded that "the overall goals of examining how environmental factors influence child health and development are meritorious and should continue to be a priority for future scientific support, but that the National Children's Study as currently designed is not feasible."

Pamela Silberman, former director of community relations for the study in Utah, said most of the people who enlisted were hopeful their participation would enact future change.

"It was so monumental and groundbreaking, as it was portrayed to them and in looking at feedback, they wanted to further science and help children's health," she said.

Silberman has many reservations as to why the study wasn't at least reconfigured on the federal level, fearing something was "amiss" as early as the pilot program began in 2005.

The study, authorized by Congress as part of the Children's Health Act of 2000, intended to decide how health is affected by genetics and what impact environment has.

"There should be a huge investigation here," she said. "A billion dollars of taxpayer money was wasted. That's a huge erosion of public trust."

Silberman's office of about 75 employees, including research assistants, recruiters and other highly trained staff, was laid off in phases, reflecting changes in the management of the study. The office was completely dissolved in May 2012, as the data was then being stored at regional sites across the U.S. and not locally.

Though she was skeptical, Silberman has remained interested in the study's findings and is working on a report about how home studies were conducted to help inform future study.


The original goals of the National Children's Study to understand genetics and environment and their relationship in health and development still remain a top priority in our country. The health of our children will determine, in many ways, the future of our country.

–Dr. Edward B. Clark, chairman of pediatrics at the U.


"I cared about the participants," she said. "I cared about the study."

The endeavor — taken up by doctors, researchers, students and participant families across the country — aspired to put scientific evidence to the nature vs. nurture question, as well as pinpoint environmental aggravates for common conditions and diseases, including autism, asthma, diabetes, attention deficit disorders, obesity and birth defects, among others.

"The need is still there. We still need to understand these questions," Silberman said. "We could have been somewhere and learned something. Kids are still unhealthy here."

In the nine years since the pilot study was launched, researchers in Japan have enacted and carried out a similar study, enlisting and tracking more than 100,000 children there.

Clark said the Japanese Environmental and Children's Study was patterned after the America's National Children's Study and, yet, is much further ahead.

His future study will include many of the same objectives, but his hypotheses are dependent upon the level of participation — he's hoping to retain many, if not all of the local National Children's Study participants — and the possibility of enlisting more participants.

"We have a commitment to the families in our community who have agreed to participate in this study," he said.

Clark said he has retained some workers from the previous study, "hoping to rebuild a team in a relatively short period of time."

He anticipates moving forward with research in the next six months and does not know of any other pilot locations or states taking on their own studies as a result of the termination of the National Children's Study.

Related stories

Most recent Utah stories

Related topics

STAY IN THE KNOW

Get informative articles and interesting stories delivered to your inbox weekly. Subscribe to the KSL.com Trending 5.
By subscribing, you acknowledge and agree to KSL.com's Terms of Use and Privacy Notice.
Newsletter Signup

KSL Weather Forecast

KSL Weather Forecast
Play button