Estimated read time: 2-3 minutes
This archived news story is available only for your personal, non-commercial use. Information in the story may be outdated or superseded by additional information. Reading or replaying the story in its archived form does not constitute a republication of the story.
SALT LAKE CITY - Questions over a decorated Utah Highway Patrol trooper's credibility are overshadowing a Salt Lake County DUI case.
Trooper Lisa Steed admitted in court Tuesday she issued a breathalyzer before a field sobriety test in a 2010 stop and she left her microphone in her cruiser -- both violations of UHP policy. The resulting reprimand was included in a section of Steed's personnel file and was determined to be admissible by 3rd District Judge Mark Kouris.
In no instance was her conduct illegal. In no instance was it immoral - or, really, legally wrong. None of these have anything to do with her integrity or her ability to carry out her functions as a law enforcement officer.
The attorney for DUI suspect Theron Alexander planned to use the disclosure to challenge Steed's credibility. Because the ordeal was verified independently in an investigation by the Salt Lake County District Attorney's Office, the information in theory could be used in other DUI cases.
Wednesday, Steed attorney Greg Skordas disputed the idea his client's actions somehow affected her credibility, saying they were simple violations of stringent UHP policy.
"In no instance was her conduct illegal. In no instance was it immoral - or, really, legally wrong," Skordas said. "None of these have anything to do with her integrity or her ability to carry out her functions as a law enforcement officer."
Still, former 30-year prosecutor Kent Morgan - who has no connection to the case - said procedural missteps can in fact be used to argue against someone's credibility.
People look at small transgressions and say that's evidence that they might not be following the rules on the bigger picture as well.
"People look at small transgressions and say that's evidence that they might not be following the rules on the bigger picture as well," Morgan said.
It isn't the first time Steed has been embroiled in a legal battle. She was sued after a 2009 stop where she deployed a taser twice on a man inside his car as he calmly asked to talk to his lawyer.
Still, Morgan warned about jumping to conclusions about Steed's conduct in Alexander's case and any of her other DUI cases.
"To draw a conclusion that everything else terrible happened in this case is not what justice is about and that's not what fact-finding is about," he said.
Alexander's case has been continued until next month, while the DUI suspect's attorney works to subpoena Steed's supervisors. Utah Highway Patrol declined comment Wednesday because of the pending nature of the Alexander case.
A request for an interview with Steed that was placed through Skordas drew no response from the trooper.
In 2007, Steed was the first woman to be named "Trooper of the Year" by UHP. She is responsible for hundreds of DUI arrests.