2 visions of conservatism collide in deep-red Idaho

Idaho's 2026 elections saw moderate Republicans regain ground in the Legislature's Magic Valley as voters pushed back against the party's increasingly conservative faction and outside political influence.

Idaho's 2026 elections saw moderate Republicans regain ground in the Legislature's Magic Valley as voters pushed back against the party's increasingly conservative faction and outside political influence. (Eliza Anderson, Deseret News)


Save Story
KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • In Idaho, conservative factions clash as right-wing candidates oust moderates in the 2024 primaries.
  • The "Gang of Eight" pushed Idaho's Legislature toward anti-government spending and social legislation.
  • Moderates regained ground in 2026, shifting Idaho's GOP dynamics amid ongoing ideological battles.

SALT LAKE CITY — Two years ago, Chenele Dixon went to the mailbox and found her own face staring back.

One day there she was, a scrapbook photo of her head stiffly clipped onto a magician's body, hypnotizing a child. Another day, she was palling it up with Michael Bloomberg, Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer. Then, fanning herself with taxpayer money alongside another Idaho state lawmaker.

In the run-up to Idaho's May 2024 Republican state legislative primary, Make Liberty Win, a conservative PAC out of Virginia, had coined Dixon and fellow Republican Rep. Steve Miller "the Con Couple." It wanted them out, and their primary opponents — running to the right of the incumbents in the 2024 May race — in. The mailers tied in with door-knocking, signage and a social media blitz that caught Dixon, her colleagues in Idaho's Magic Valley and many mainstream Republicans off guard. And it worked: Right-wing conservatives ousted all four moderate incumbents in districts around Twin Falls, the agricultural backbone of the state's southern tier.

The Magic Valley's primaries built the core of Idaho's self-declared "Gang of Eight," an ideologically pristine group of lawmakers who helped propel the state Legislature's shift toward intense opposition to government spending, aggressive budget cuts, interventionist social legislation and fierce enforcement of the party's expanding platform. In the process, they helped cement the status of Idaho, already on the vanguard of modern right-wing governance, as a laboratory for a new strain of conservative thought — a stage where a few lawmakers could push once-fringe policy into the state, and sometimes national, spotlight.

Just over a month after the first of 21 mailers, Dixon was out of a job. In losing, though, she found another one.

For the next two years, Dixon and a clutch of other centrist Republicans laid the groundwork for a successful counterrevolution in the Magic Valley, ousting three of the four incumbents that won in 2024 with candidates closer to the state's political center. Now, she's taking the blueprint to other parts of Idaho as competing factions of the GOP wrestle for control of a single-party state.

In the Nov. 3 midterm, general election voters made it official, knocking the original Gang of Eight down to a group of three. Idahoans elected five relative moderates in their place. The "blue wave" that surged through much of the country broadly missed Idaho; Democrats flipped a handful of legislative seats, but the GOP's Statehouse supermajority easily held up. What appears to have changed, at least in some parts of the state, is the shade of red they send to Boise.

"We spent the last two years working really hard to make a change," said former state Rep. Linda Wright Hartgen, who was beaten by Josh Kohl, a more conservative challenger, in 2024 and spent the ensuing two years organizing precinct committees and mobilizing voters across Twin Falls County. "And we made quite a change."

'You cannot win without an R next to your name'

In most of Idaho, November elections are coronations. Republicans hold every statewide office and, when the Legislature convenes in January, 80% of both chambers of the Statehouse. Here, flipping a seat doesn't mean changing its color, it means changing its shade, said Jaclyn Kettler, a political science professor at Boise State University.

"When we talk about flipping seats here, we're usually talking about primaries," Kettler said. "We're flipping from one ideological faction to another." In much of Idaho, that pits "hard-line social conservatives" against "more moderate conservatives." On state ballots, the challenge "is not letting up," she said.

Over the past decade or so, Hartgen said, traditional "Reagan Republicans" have been falling behind. This year, the GOP's platform swelled to 36 pages. Two years ago, it was 20. The update proposes ambitious projects inside the state boundaries and out, like nullifying federal authority within Idaho's borders, repealing the 17th Amendment that established the direct election of U.S. senators, and abolishing the Federal Reserve in favor of a return to the gold standard. Socially, it favors an abortion ban without exception, and doesn't think state money should fund higher education.

Hartgen, a "pro-life, pro-family" Republican who has spent her whole life in Idaho, described the June convention as "bedlam."

"I'd sit there and say, 'What am I doing here?'" she said. "Our votes just didn't count. They got everything they wanted."

The question at the heart of the convention, and in the state's primaries: What should the Republican Party represent in Idaho, and who should represent it?

In January, state party Chairwoman Dorothy Moon published an op-ed on the Idaho GOP website titled "How to Identify a Real Republican."

"You know, people are always asking me how to tell a real Republican from a fake one, or how to identify a true conservative," wrote Moon. "Are there Democrats masquerading as Republicans?"

Moon, who earned a reputation as one of the state's most conservative lawmakers while serving in the Idaho House of Representatives, went on to warn voters against candidates who "echo left-wing talking points like 'common sense background checks'" for gun ownership, vote against tax cuts, or "hide behind left-wing euphemisms like 'women's healthcare' or 'reproductive health.'"

On social media and in campaign materials, members of the Gang of Eight billed themselves as "true conservatives" and their more moderate opponents as belonging to "the establishment." In a May Substack post, Twin Falls Rep. David Leavitt, one of the Gang of Eight, described the Gang's primary challengers as "products of the government class — city councils, county commissions, state agencies, industries directly tied to government spending and policy." (Leavitt did not respond to a request for comment.)

"They are not outsiders challenging the system," Leavitt wrote. "They are the system, seeking to protect itself from the people who came to limit it. … And they know that in Idaho, you cannot win without an R next to your name. So the strategy is not to abandon the Republican Party. It is to use it."

Sen. Glenneda Zuiderveld, another member of the Gang of Eight, lost her 2026 primary to challenger Brent Reinke, a Twin Falls County commissioner. In a public Facebook post, Zuiderveld echoed Leavitt's accusations of more moderate Republicans "using" the GOP and lamented "third- and fourth-generation Idahoans Californicating Idaho."

Zuiderveld did not respond to a request for comment.

This "is why people are fed up with the Republican Party," Zuiderveld wrote. "The tent is so big these days that it's full of clowns and monkeys. Leadership keeps allowing people to use the party and not keeping them accountable."

On that point — that the party's big tent may have overstretched its capacity limits — Zuiderveld and Hartgen can agree.

"I really hate the saying that there's room in the tent for everybody, because, quite frankly, there isn't," Hartgen said. "We've got to all be on the same playing field, or it's going to go amok."

Republican Rep. Jack Nelsen, from nearby Jerome, will retire from the Statehouse at the end of the year. Recently, he's stopped following the state GOP conventions — which he describes as increasingly "radical" — altogether, he said.

"I've been a Republican forever," Nelsen said, "but they're making it really hard to be a Republican."

Idaho is 'a cheap date'

In 2024, Magic Valley became an unlikely beachhead for the party's right wing. Filled with dairies and farmland, it's an ag-dependent region in what's still an ag-heavy state. Twin Falls, the seat of the county that bears its name, sits at the center of the state's $12 billion annual agriculture and agribusiness industry, according to the most recent data from the University of Idaho. Four of every 10 Magic Valley jobs at the time of that survey were tied to food production, according to the Idaho Farm Bureau.

"The Magic Valley has always been considered the steady Eddie of the state," Dixon said. "They could be counted on to make good decisions. And all of a sudden, that was gone."

Down-ballot elections come down to crops, commerce and classrooms — including those at the College of Southern Idaho, a two-year school that educates a chunk of the area's workforce, according to Nelsen, a dairyman by trade.

That blend of issues can give Magic Valley politics an old-fashioned feel. Lawmakers attend irrigation district meetings, Hartgen said. They drop in on school boards. They set up booths at county fairs and sit there for days on end. During campaign season, they knock on a lot of doors.

These steps work in part because candidates don't have to reach that many voters, Kettler said. Districts are geographically large, but sparsely populated. By rule, only registered Republicans can vote in those races, further limiting the voter pool. Hartgen lost to Josh Kohl by 1,300 votes in a race where around 4,700 people cast ballots. Kohl won unopposed in the general election six months later with around 14,000 votes. (Kohl didn't respond to requests for comment.)

"When you talk to people in Idaho, it seems like some of the retail politics in campaigns can matter a lot — mailers, door-knocking, those types of things," Kettler said. "Groups see Idaho and think, it's not that expensive to campaign here and potentially get a policy win."

More and more, Kettler said outside groups are focusing on state legislatures for that reason: efficiency. Independent expenditures are on the rise in Idaho, she said, because you "can get a lot of impact per dollar spent."

Or, as Nelsen put it, "Idaho is a cheap date."

"For a few million dollars, you can get bills pushed onto a national stage that I don't think any Idahoan on Main Street would agree with," he said.

Millions is an overstatement. Make Liberty Win spent less than $19,000 to help defeat Dixon in 2024, according to campaign finance filings with the Idaho secretary of state. Her opponent, Rep. Clint Hostetler, also won his 2026 primary and retained his seat against an independent challenger this fall. Hostetler didn't respond to a request for comment.

'You're stabbing yourself in the foot'

Dixon kept all the mailers, plus a voter guide from an outside group that she said misrepresented her record. She still has them in a file: Claims that she voted to put porn in libraries, to confiscate guns, to ban hunting for shed antlers — a niche issue, but one that she said cost her votes with outdoorsmen.

"We had never seen anything like that," Dixon added. "We've never had a negative campaign around here."

Idaho has seen a huge influx of people from bigger states. Now, they were seeing large-market politics.

Twin Falls City Council Member Cherie Vollmer beat Leavitt in May. Prior to the election, she spoke to a legislator and a precinct committeeman who had both moved to the area from California. They laughed — they'd found the 2024 campaign tame.

"What is it they say? Fear and drama always get the clicks," she said.

Vollmer thinks her campaign won by moving in the other direction: longer conversations, educational events, and face-to-face meetings. She credits a sense of decorum, and allowing room for debate.

"We can agree 80% of the time, and be good with that," she said. "We don't have to agree 90%, 95%, 100% of the time. I don't even know a single household that agrees 100% of the time, and that's healthy."

To other Idaho conservatives, total ideological agreement is paramount. The Idaho Freedom Foundation, an influential right-wing think tank and conservative lobby, grades every politician on how closely every lawmaker's votes align with the organization's social values and spending goal. The Gang of Eight all earned As and A+s on the report card; Dixon, Nelsen and Hartgen each got Fs.

Nelsen, who is retiring at the end of the year, likes the Freedom Foundation about as much as it liked his votes. Still, he can't deny its influence on how some Idaho Republicans — particularly newcomers — make laws.

Hartgen agreed.

"You know you're stabbing yourself in the foot when you (vote against the Freedom Foundation)," she said, "but that's what the people elected you to do."

'Candidates matter'

Heading into 2026, Dixon's plan was to make sure the record cut both ways. That meant explaining how lawmakers voted, often in great detail. She found help in the community in which she was raised.

Dixon founded Idaho Solutions, a nonprofit civic group, and began bringing lectures around the region and, eventually, the state. Topics included healthcare, school choice, immigration, civil discourse and the influence of Christian nationalism on state affairs. The organization didn't endorse specific candidates this year. It held town halls and answered questions. It published a voter guide, too, like the one Dixon credits for dinging her reputation in 2024.

People responded to the "more neighborly" approach, said Vollmer, who won her November general election with more than 62% of the vote. The candidates that won the Magic Valley in May were "more community minded," she believes, and more focused on local issues.

In Nelsen's view, incumbents' opposition to government spending — which meant voting against community college funding and in favor of school-choice vouchers, even though many small towns don't have a private or parochial school to use them on — worked against them on Election Day.

Another of the "big dividing lines in the Legislature this year," according to Kettler: agriculture.

Agriculture was a place where party lines and business interests came into conflict, she said. Dairies rely heavily on immigrant labor, and talk in favor of aggressive immigration enforcement at the Statehouse all winter rubbed many the wrong way, Nelsen said. Then, spending hawks voted against appropriations for water infrastructure — an affront to powerful farming interests in the Magic Valley.

"That was the last straw," Nelsen said. "You don't take a farmer's water away from them and you don't put it in jeopardy. To me, that was the headliner."

Voters responded by picking more pragmatic candidates, he said.

Now, Dixon is betting her approach in the Magic Valley can work elsewhere.

That may not be easy, Kettler said. While voters in southern Idaho picked more "mainstream" candidates, hard-liners won in Northern Idaho, for example, a lynchpin of the state's rightward drift.

"We're not seeing consistent results throughout the entire state, with one faction being more successful than another," Kettler said. "We kind of have mixed results."

To her, it points to local dynamics.

"Ideology plays a role," she said, "but candidates matter. Campaigns still matter."

The Key Takeaways for this article were generated with the assistance of large language models and reviewed by our editorial team. The article, itself, is solely human-written.

Most recent Politics stories

Related topics

STAY IN THE KNOW

Get informative articles and interesting stories delivered to your inbox weekly. Subscribe to the KSL.com Trending 5.
By subscribing, you acknowledge and agree to KSL.com's Terms of Use and Privacy Notice.
Newsletter Signup

KSL Weather Forecast

KSL Weather Forecast
Play button