Estimated read time: 5-6 minutes
SALT LAKE CITY — When a Utah judge at the heart of Utah’s redistricting case was targeted with threats last fall, the KSL Investigators began looking deeper at how often judges are threatened – and how those cases are handled. Public records reveal a broader pattern: disturbing and sometimes violent threats against judges are not always formally reviewed for prosecution. KSL Investigators reviewed records involving threats against the Third District Court over the past five years. Those cases are typically handled by the Salt Lake County Sheriff’s Office.
Few cases move forward
The records provided pointed to seven cases. One remains under investigation. That is the most recent threat case, which was reported last fall. The Salt Lake County Sheriff’s Office has released little information on the case other than that a death threat was issued against Judge Dianna Gibson shortly after she issued a ruling in the state’s redistricting process. In that ruling, she rejected a congressional map the Republican-controlled Utah Legislature proposed in favor of one proposed by voter groups. Two additional cases were referred to other agencies, one of which resulted in charges. That involved a man who admitted to sending a letter threatening to kill a judge and others in a courtroom in 2020. He later pleaded guilty to a felony and was sentenced to up to five years in prison. But four others show that serious threats, many involving explicit violence, were closed without being formally submitted to the Salt Lake County District Attorney’s screening system. That system is required before prosecutors can independently evaluate whether criminal charges should be filed.
Graphic threats documented
Those threats came in different forms — voicemails, emails, and messages left at courthouses. In one voicemail obtained by KSL Investigates, a caller warned, “Judge […] better be in jail … if they are not, I will take care of them.” Other threats went further. In emails sent to court staff, one person wrote, “What’s going to happen is me coming to the courthouse and destroying it … I hope you … are in the building when I do.”
Why were cases closed
When KSL Investigates asked the Salt Lake County Sheriff’s Office why multiple cases were not referred to prosecutors for screening, the agency declined an interview but wrote in an email that investigators must first determine whether a crime occurred and whether sufficient evidence exists before submitting a case for prosecution review. Inside the case files, investigators also outlined reasons for closing cases without submitting them for review. For example, in 2020, a letter addressed to a judge included language calling for mass violence and stated that anyone who challenged the author would “be put to death, along with their entire families.” Despite being addressed to a specific judge and containing violent language, investigators concluded the letter did not contain a direct threat toward a particular person as defined under state law. Investigators wrote in the case file that there was not sufficient content to support criminal charges, and the case was closed as information only. In a 2021 case, a letter addressed to a judge contained explicit violent statements naming multiple judges, including threats of bodily harm. The closing narrative in the report states the investigator contacted a supervisor to ask whether further follow-up or charges were needed, and was told there was nothing further to pursue. The report remained informational only. In a 2023 case, an investigator wrote that a suspect refused to meet in a controlled environment, creating safety concerns for law enforcement. The report states that a supervisor consulted with the district attorney’s office, and it was decided there was insufficient evidence to prosecute, citing the inability to obtain an interview and difficulty in establishing the suspect’s location. The district attorney’s office told KSL Investigates it has no record of that interaction because the case was not formally submitted for screening. The sheriff’s office told KSL they are aware of the District Attorney’s screening policy, but distinguished between consultation with prosecutors and formal submission, writing that investigators may consult with prosecutors during an investigation without formally logging the case for screening. But Salt Lake County District Attorney Sim Gill said consultation alone does not trigger an official review by his office. Without a formal submission, he says prosecutors cannot independently evaluate whether criminal charges should be filed.
Threats are widespread statewide
Gill said threats against public officials are becoming more common and are likely to continue. Statewide, the scope of the issue is significant. Over the past three years, judges and employees in Utah’s judiciary have received an average of 163 threatening communications per year statewide, according to the Utah State Courts. “Every threatening communication is carefully evaluated and, when appropriate, reported to law enforcement,” a spokesperson for the Utah State Courts said. “Whether or not reported to law enforcement, all threatening communications are taken seriously.”
Related Story: Nearly half of Utah legal professionals report experiencing threats
Responses may range from helping judges and employees develop personal safety plans, to requesting law enforcement agencies to provide individual protection. Have you experienced something you think just isn’t right? The KSL Investigators want to help. Submit your tip at investigates@ksl.com or 385‑707‑6153 so we can get working for you.
This story was adapted from a TV broadcast script using artificial intelligence. Every story, including those adapted with AI, is reviewed by a human editor before publication to ensure that KSL's editorial standards are upheld.









