Richfield man awaiting new sentence after two decades of life in prison without parole

Morris T. Mullins was sentenced to life in prison without parole for aggravated murder after admitting to killing a Richfield woman in her home in 2001. His sentence was vacated, and he is now awaiting a new sentence.

Morris T. Mullins was sentenced to life in prison without parole for aggravated murder after admitting to killing a Richfield woman in her home in 2001. His sentence was vacated, and he is now awaiting a new sentence. (Utah Department of Corrections)


Save Story
KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • Morris Mullins awaits resentencing after the U.S. Supreme Court declined to consider a ruling that his life without parole sentence was unconstitutional.
  • The Richfield man was sentenced at 18 after being convicted of killing an elderly woman when he was 17.
  • A new sentencing date is pending while attorneys review the legal requirements; a status conference is set for Dec. 15.

RICHFIELD — Morris Mullins attended a hearing from jail on Tuesday after spending decades of his life in prison, without the possibility of parole. But his sentence is now officially reversed, and he will now be sentenced again in Sixth District Court.

The U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal of a Utah decision that found his life without the possibility of parole sentence was unconstitutional because he was 17 at the time he committed the crime.

Mullins was 18 when he was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole for aggravated murder, a capital offense. Now, he is 43. He argued that his sentence violated the Eighth Amendment because there is no indication the judge considered his age.

He pleaded guilty in December 2001 to the aggravated murder of 78-year-old Amy Davis at her Richfield home in May of that year. His plea deal removed the possibility of the death penalty.

The Utah Supreme Court ruled in favor of Mullins last year, on Nov. 20, 2025. The majority on the Utah Supreme Court cited a comment from the judge in his sentencing suggesting a "hope" that Mullins may have "a chance to change." They determined the juvenile life without parole sentence was "incompatible with a suggestion that Mullins could change."

On Oct. 19, the U.S. Supreme Court denied a request from the state for them to consider the case, making the state high court's order final.

An order to move him to the Sevier County Jail, since he is no longer sentenced to prison, was signed on Nov. 5.

The judge will soon sentence Mullins again, but before that, attorneys will need to look at the legal requirements for his sentence under the laws in 2001.

Benji McMurray was appointed as a federal public defender, and now that the case is not about whether his sentence was constitutional, he is no longer being paid to represent him. The attorney said he would be willing to represent Mullins for his sentencing if the county set up a contract with him, but on Tuesday, Van Dyke appointed a local public defender.

Instead of scheduling the long-awaited new sentencing, a status conference was set for Dec. 15, where attorneys may be ready to schedule the sentencing. Van Dyke also said he would be requesting an updated pre-sentence investigation report for him to refer to at the sentencing.

In 2007, Mullins was convicted in Arizona of killing another elderly woman weeks before Davis' death.

He also pleaded guilty in 2022 to aggravated assault by a prisoner, a third-degree felony, at the Utah State Prison in 2017. Mullins pleaded guilty to assault on a correctional officer, a class A misdemeanor, in 2005 and three times to damaging jails, a third-degree felony, in 2001.

Mullins spoke up during his hearing and asked to read a letter, which his attorney advised him not to do. McMurray explained the letter was a request for him to be moved, possibly back to the prison or to a different county's jail. The attorney said there are some memories and feelings from when Mullins was in the jail about 20 years ago that are "difficult for him to navigate."

According to Mullins, he is "feeling manic," having bad dreams, and he is being locked up for 23 hours of the day.

Judge Robert Van Dyke said he does not think a transfer is possible, but he told prosecutors to look into it and said he would sign an order if both parties agreed,

The Key Takeaways for this article were generated with the assistance of large language models and reviewed by our editorial team. The article, itself, is solely human-written.

Related stories

Most recent Police & Courts stories

Related topics

STAY IN THE KNOW

Get informative articles and interesting stories delivered to your inbox weekly. Subscribe to the KSL.com Trending 5.
By subscribing, you acknowledge and agree to KSL.com's Terms of Use and Privacy Notice.
Newsletter Signup

KSL Weather Forecast

KSL Weather Forecast
Play button