Holy Score: Breaking down BYU's path into the playoff and the perils of the Big 12 title game


Save Story

Estimated read time: 6-7 minutes

Following his brief appearance on the College Football Playoff ranking show Tuesday night, selection committee chair Hunter Yurachek held a media teleconference in which he plunged into the weeds of the third edition.

Yurachek, the athletic director at Arkansas, addressed a slew of issues — from the gap between No. 2 Utah and everyone else to Miami's fate to the treatment of Ohio State and Oregon to the committee's overall view of the SEC. In total, he fielded 22 questions involving all but a few of the 25 teams.

BYU, ranked 10th for the second consecutive week, was mentioned once, in a question about the difference between the Cougars and No. 11 Wake Forest.

Yurachek offered a two-sentence response, and the Q&A moved on to other matters.

We'll get to the details of the exchange momentarily, but the bigger picture is hard to miss: A team that was on the outside of the CFP looking in the past two seasons — to the immense frustration of its fans and stakeholders — is on the right side of the cutline.

Were the playoff to begin this week, the Cougars would make the field with one spot to spare, as the 10th seed, and face No. 7 Miami on the road in the opening round.

Don't forget: In the 12-team format, the highest-ranked Group of Six team receives an automatic bid. That team is No. 17 Boise State, which would take the final spot and knock out No. 12.

Put another way: No. 11 is the last team in the field.

Right now, that team is Wake Forest, sitting one spot below BYU. The Cougars have some margin for error, but not much.

What are the chances of BYU making the cut? If the Cougars win the Big 12 championship, their chances are 100%. They would receive the conference's automatic bid.

But if Texas Tech (6-1 in Big 12 play) beats Baylor and TCU, the Red Raiders would climb into the conference championship against Utah (7-0), which is essentially a lock for Arlington.

BYU (5-2) lost control of its own destiny when it lost the Holy War — well, when it lost at UCF and then lost the Holy War.

At the moment, the Allstate Playoff Predictor published by ESPN gives the Cougars a 56% chance to make the CFP.

If they reach the conference championship and lose — we cannot emphasize this enough — their outlook arguably would be worse: A three-loss Big 12 runner-up would be an easy removal for the selection committee, which has been known to take the path of least (public) resistance.

The Cougars might be better off beating Kansas and Cincinnati to finish 10-2, watching Utah and Texas Tech play for the title and taking their chances with the at-large field.

Which brings us to Yurachek's comment on the media teleconference Tuesday night.

Here's the question:

"I would love to get your thoughts on Wake Forest just being right outside of the top 10, BYU being above them, the difference you see between those two teams right now."

And his response:

"I think the biggest difference between those two teams is BYU's win over Notre Dame. Wake Forest doesn't have the same type of win on their resume right now. That's going to be the separation between those two teams."

Had Yurachek been so inclined, he could have added the following: Only one team contending for the at-large field has a victory on its resume comparable to BYU's win over the sixth-ranked Irish.

That team would be No. 9 Tennessee, which beat No. 3 Alabama.

None of the other teams within four spots of the CFP cutline (above or below) have aces on their resumes like Notre Dame for BYU and Alabama for Tennessee.

Now, let's dive into three scenarios that could endanger BYU's drive for an at-large bid, which each team's ranking included for clarity:

— Could No. 11 Wake Forest jump the Cougars?

It's unlikely. The Demon Deacons finish the regular season against unranked opponents (Duke and Georgia Tech) that lack the resume rocket fuel needed for them to vault BYU.

And the Deacons certainly won't overtake BYU if they advance to the ACC championship and lose to Miami.

If they beat the Hurricanes, the Deacons would receive the automatic bid. But then Miami would have two losses and presumably struggle in a resume showdown with BYU (for an at-large berth) because the Hurricanes lost to Notre Dame.

Another factor working in BYU's favor: Arizona is No. 17, which means the Cougars have two wins over ranked teams. Wake Forest and Miami have one each.

— Could No. 12 Texas Tech jump the Cougars?

This is a fascinating scenario because it involves the Big 12 eating its own.

The 12th-ranked Red Raiders are currently the first team out — remember: No. 17 Boise State receives an automatic bid — and don't have much juice left in the schedule with unranked Baylor and TCU remaining.

Nor would the Red Raiders threaten BYU if they advanced to the Big 12 championship and lost to Utah.

That said, the situation turns a tad tricky if Texas Tech wins the conference. The accompanying automatic bid would knock Utah into the at-large pool, gobbling one of the seven spots that BYU covets.

But in theory, the Cougars have some cushion because No. 11 Wake Forest is currently the last team in the field. The combination of Texas Tech winning the Big 12 and Utah joining the at-large pool would knock out the Demon Deacons, not the Cougars.

— Could No. 13 Oregon or No. 14 Ohio State jump the Cougars?

The grouping of Big Ten teams in the mid-teens was a hot topic on the media teleconference with Yurachek, especially considering the Ducks and Buckeyes have three losses.

Only two teams with three losses have made the CFP. Both played in their conference championship games and were 10-3 on selection day: Clemson won the ACC in 2024; Alabama lost the SEC title game in 2025.

No team with a 9-3 record has been included in the field. Could Oregon or Ohio State be the first?

Predicting exactly what the committee will do from week to week is a fool's errand. But Neither Oregon nor Ohio State will face a ranked team in the final two weeks, thus limiting their resume upside.

It's difficult to envision three-loss teams jumping a two-loss team that's multiple spots ahead without beating a ranked opponent.

If either the Ducks or Buckeyes sneak into the Big Ten championship — both are alive, believe it or not — then one of two outcomes would unfold:

— They lose and are eliminated from CFP contention with a 9-4 record.

— They win, claim the automatic bid and knock UCLA or Indiana into the at-large field. But again, that would push No. 11 Wake Forest below the cutline.

Step back, and BYU's dots are fairly easy to connect:

The victory over Notre Dame has allowed the Cougars to hold their No. 10 spot, which, in turn, gives them crucial cushion in case an upset in the ACC, Big Ten or Big 12 championship games creates an extra at-large team.

If they win out, they should hold their ground. And if they hold their ground, they should make the cut.

But in the unpredictable, counterintuitive world of the CFP selections, advancing to the Big 12 championship could complicate matters for the Cougars.

Most recent Big 12 stories

Related topics

KSL.com Beyond Series

KSL Weather Forecast

KSL Weather Forecast
Play button