Police: Idaho woman stole items from victim in mall shooting

Police and emergency crews respond to a reported shooting at the Boise Towne Square shopping mall Oct. 25 in Boise, Idaho. An Idaho woman was jailed after police say she stole from the body of a security guard killed during the shooting.

Police and emergency crews respond to a reported shooting at the Boise Towne Square shopping mall Oct. 25 in Boise, Idaho. An Idaho woman was jailed after police say she stole from the body of a security guard killed during the shooting. (Darin Oswald/Idaho Statesman via AP)



Estimated read time: 2-3 minutes

BOISE, Idaho — A 54-year-old Idaho woman was jailed after police say she stole from the body of a security guard killed during a Boise mall shooting.

Mary Alyce Scarbrough of Boise is charged with felony counts of alteration of evidence, malicious injury to property and grand theft, The Idaho Statesman reported Wednesday. She's being held without bail on accusations of violating her parole, as well as on a $250,000 bond on the other charges.

"The court's very concerned about the alleged conduct in this case," said Magistrate Judge David Manweiler during a court hearing last week.

Court documents list Amy Mitchell as Scarbrough's attorney. Mitchell is also listed as an attorney with the Ada County public defender's office. That office declined to comment Wednesday when contacted by The Associated Press.

Security guard Jo Acker, 26, died in the shooting. Roberto Padilla Arguelles, a 49-year-old Rupert man shopping for gifts for his family, was also killed.

Police say that minutes later they exchanged gunfire with 27-year-old suspect Jacob Bergquist, who died the next day.

Prosecutors said Scarbrough was inside the mall when the shooting began.

"The defendant approached the dying security guard at the mall," a prosecutor said during Scarbrough's court appearance. The complaint said that Scarbrough took rings, a gun belt, clothing and other property from Acker's body.

"A woman experiencing a mental health crisis significantly altered the crime scene by removing and displacing evidence throughout the mall," Boise Police Department spokeswoman Haley Williams said in an email to the newspaper.


A woman experiencing a mental health crisis significantly altered the crime scene by removing and displacing evidence throughout the mall.

–Haley Williams, Boise Police Department


According to court records, Scarbrough also went into an arcade and tore off sheets of metal, kicked holes in walls and damaged other items.

Scarbrough was booked into the Ada County Jail on the day of the shooting on a misdemeanor disturbing the peace charge and was in custody when charged with the felony counts.

She has pleaded not guilty to disturbing the peace.

Scarbrough is on probation from a felony drug case after pleading in 2019 to possession of a controlled substance.

Related Stories

The Associated Press

    SIGN UP FOR THE KSL.COM NEWSLETTER

    Catch up on the top news and features from KSL.com, sent weekly.
    By subscribing, you acknowledge and agree to KSL.com's Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

    KSL Weather Forecast