Utahns love their desserts — and nowhere is that more evident than in Utah County, where you'll find one of the best assortments of sweet spots in the state.
From Lehi to Santaquin and everywhere in between, there's something to satisfy just about any craving.
Sure, ice cream is a must, but you'll also find fun, artsy places where the experience is just as memorable as the treats — sometimes even offering full meals to go with your dessert.
If you're hungry and ready to indulge, here's your guide to the best desserts and ice cream in the valley.
Brooker's Founding Flavors Ice Cream
With more than 2,000 Google reviews and a 4.8-star rating, Brooker's Founding Flavors Ice Cream is a clear crowd-pleaser.
Its plucky colonial theme and revolutionary flavors — like Aaron Burr's Murderous Shot and Patrick Henry's Give Me Chocolate or Give Me Death — make it as entertaining as it is delicious. The atmosphere adds to the charm, but the ice cream is the real star.
"This place is the best. The ice cream is so rich, flavorful and unique," one Google reviewer raves.
It's no surprise, then, that Brooker's has repeatedly been crowned Best Ice Cream and Best Dessert in Utah County, three years in a row.
Penguin Brothers
When you can't choose between cookies and ice cream, Penguin Brothers lets you have both.
Their gourmet ice cream sandwiches are the best of both worlds — and guaranteed to make your mouth water.
Try the Frequent Flyer (Biscoff ice cream between snickerdoodle cookies) or Luigi's Mansion (Oreo mint ice cream between two double fudge cookies), or pick any combo from their crave-worthy menu.
Rockwell Ice Cream
Rockwell Ice Cream is fresh, locally sourced and handmade daily, with unique and unforgettable flavors.
It's no wonder this spot is a perennial favorite among ice cream lovers. Try their signature G.O.A.T. or rich Honeycomb flavors and you'll never look at ice cream the same way again.
Rowley's Red Barn
Santaquin may be a small town, but it's big on flavor — thanks to the now-iconic Rowley's Red Barn, home to some of the best ice cream and made-from-scratch donuts around. Come for the apple picking, stay for the ice cream!
BYU Creamery on Ninth
Ice cream from the BYU Creamery has long been a legendary staple in Utah County, and their Provo location on Ninth adds even more to love with a full menu of comfort food favorites.
Don't leave without trying their signature flavors like Graham Canyon and Ernestly Chocolate — local legends in their own right.
The Dessert Collective
The Dessert Collective in American Fork is a must-visit for foodies eager to sample the best from local artisans.
With an ever-changing assortment of coconut creams, hand pies, macarons, cookies and brownies, there's something for every sweet tooth. And if that's not enough to tempt you, the rave reviews speak for themselves.
"10/10 recommend going!" a Google reviewer writes. "I love this concept, four different businesses coming together for so many options that are ALL delicious. Definitely recommend the sampler, where you get to pick four different desserts—you won't regret it!"
Art City Sweets and The RagaMuffin
Art City Sweets and The RagaMuffin may be a newer name in the dessert scene, but it's already winning over locals with its charm and flavor-packed offerings. With a growing collection of five-star Google reviews, this bakery is quickly becoming a neighborhood favorite.
"Our new summer go-to!" one reviewer writes. "The gelato is packed with flavor and the peanut butter chews are my kids' favorite!"
Just Add Chocolate in Lehi
When you're craving more than just dessert and want a full experience to go with it, Just Add Chocolate in Lehi delivers.
Marketed as a place "where sweet memories are made," this hands-on chocolate factory invites you to become a chocolatier in a fun, hour-long workshop.
Watch a demo, make your own custom creations, sample a variety of treats and take home your delicious, handcrafted masterpieces. It's the perfect mix of dessert stop and date night activity all rolled into one!
"I cannot say enough good things about this place," a Google reviewer writes. "We booked the chocolate-making workshop and it was a blast! So many fillings and flavors to try. There was disco lights and music. Reasonable price for the chocolate and it tasted good too!"
Lighthouse Donut, Coffee & Dessert Co.
If donuts are more your style, look no further than Lighthouse Donut, Coffee & Dessert Co.
This place is quickly gaining a reputation for its fresh, made-from-scratch treats that emphasize quality and simplicity.
"Their donuts are super fresh, the softest you've had, and you can tell they use quality, organic, simple ingredients to concoct these donuts!" a Yelp reviewer raves.
The Twisted Cow
Another highly rated ice cream stop in Provo that deserves a spot on your post-hike list is The Twisted Cow.
Fans love the top-notch quality, creative rotating flavors and upbeat atmosphere. Bonus: If you buy a jar, you can bring it back next time for a discounted refill!
Hungry for more?
Believe it or not, this list is just the beginning. From hidden gems to longtime local favorites, there are even more dessert destinations waiting to be discovered. Visit utahvalley.com for the full scoop on where to satisfy your sweet tooth in Utah County.
