Yukai Peng, KSL

With car caravan and rally, teachers urge schools to pump brakes on reopening

By Annie Knox, KSL | Posted - Aug. 7, 2020 at 8:24 p.m.



SALT LAKE CITY — More than 100 teachers and their supporters gathered at the Utah Capitol Friday, sporting face masks and standing at least six feet apart as they urged stricter school reopening plans.

With chants of “We love science” and “It’s not too late,” the group called for greater oversight from health officials and a half-capacity attendance cap in communities with positive test rates over 5%. They also emphasized a need for better communication with families, especially those whose primary languages are not English.

Utah Education Association executive director Brad Bartels said there is still time to build on the union’s earlier successful efforts to strengthen precautions for the quickly advancing school year.

Under pressure from the union and others, state health and education officials Thursday changed course and issued new guidance directing students and teachers to stay home for two weeks after exposure to the virus, not just when they have symptoms.

Speakers at Friday’s rally called the state’s approach too lax and said it disregards the very science and critical thinking it requires students to learn.

Brian Moench with Utah Physicians for a Healthy Environment denounced claims that children can’t get sick, noting a 7-year-old boy in Georgia is the latest child confirmed to die of the virus.

Second grade schoolteacher John Cederlund hoists and twists a handmade sign during a rally to show support for opening schools safely at the Capitol in Salt Lake City on Friday, Aug. 7, 2020. (Photo: Yukai Peng, KSL)

“Teachers have endured criticism, bitterness and bullying for simply not wanting to sacrifice their lives and those of their students on the altar of political expediency,” Moench said, addressing the group remotely over a phone. “If our schools are not safe, none of us are safe.”

Ana Alcala said schools on the west side of the Salt Lake Valley have largely failed to release reopening plans in Spanish even as Utah’s Hispanic community has been hardest hit by the virus.

“We need to keep the Latinx community in mind,” she told the Deseret News.

Two dozen of the state’s 41 districts are allowing students to return full time. Just one, Salt Lake City, is keeping its doors closed and beginning the year teaching fully online. The remainder are holding a mix of in-person and remote lessons.

No family is required to send a child to school. The state has allowed them to opt for remote lessons if they don’t feel comfortable.

The Utah Board of Education is allowing districts wide latitude in crafting reopening plans, but masks are required. The board on Thursday rejected a series of stronger statewide standards, including limits on in-person attendance when positive test rates top 5%, the threshold set by the World Health Organization.

Eighth grade history teacher Katie Barney, left, and her sister Emerald hold signs during a rally to show support for opening schools safely at the Capitol in Salt Lake City on Friday, Aug. 7, 2020. (Photo: Yukai Peng, KSL)

Supporters said the tweaks would help prevent outbreaks that would force a total shutdown. Opponents said they did not allow enough flexibility for schools to craft their own plans based on local needs.

Several of the demonstrators Friday drove up State Street with messages on car windows such as “Only when it’s safe!” On the Capitol lawn, they held signs saying “Science is real; So are teachers,” and “Won’t somebody please think of the children?”

State School Board member and teacher Jennifer Graviet said a former student described feeling terrified that teachers, parents and children will get sick and die. The student emailed Graviet to say she didn’t want a page in the yearbook dedicated to those who succumb to the virus.

“We need to tap into our empathy and compassion,” Graviet said.

Related Stories

Annie Knox

KSL Weather Forecast