White nationalist, opponent charged in Sacramento melee

White nationalist, opponent charged in Sacramento melee

By Don Thompson, Associated Press | Posted - Jul. 18, 2017 at 10:25 p.m.

1 photo

This archived news story is available only for your personal, non-commercial use. Information in the story may be outdated or superseded by additional information. Reading or replaying the story in its archived form does not constitute a republication of the story.

SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — California authorities announced charges Tuesday against a white nationalist and a counter-protester after a violent melee outside the California state Capitol building last year, a number that falls far short of the 101 people the California Highway Patrol recommended charging.

The charges stem from June 2016, when 14 people came away with stab wounds, cuts and bruises after more than 300 counter-protesters, many of them wearing masks, confronted about 30 members of the white-nationalist Traditionalist Worker Party. Two of the injured people survived critical stabbings.

The Sacramento County District Attorney's Office said other arrests are expected, but prosecutors rejected numerous other charges the highway patrol sought after its eight-month investigation.

Investigators could not learn the identities of those committing the most violent offenses, Chief Deputy District Attorney Steve Grippi said in a statement, and the district attorney's office is not pursuing many of the more minor recommended charges.

A KCRA-TV reporter and his cameraman were confronted by protesters who shouted "no cameras" as they grabbed at their equipment.

The stabbings and the assault on the TV crew were clearly felonies, but no charges can be filed because investigators never learned who was responsible, Grippi said.

The two arrests were on charges of assault with a deadly weapon or using force likely to cause great bodily harm and participating in a riot.

William Planer, who prosecutors say was supporting the Traditionalist Worker Party, was arrested in Colorado and is awaiting extradition to California. Prosecutors did not know if Planer had retained an attorney.

Porfirio Paz was arrested in Southern California and is set to be arraigned July 24. Prosecutors believe Paz, who is from Long Beach, was a counter-protester.

His attorney, Mark Reichel, said Paz has no criminal record and plans to plead not guilty.

"I don't know why they charged him but he will beat the charges," Reichel said.

Representatives from both sides did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Police in Colorado Springs, Colorado, are holding a William Scott Planer, 34, for extradition to California, department spokesman Lt. Howard Black said.

Planer was arrested July 12 on suspicion of committing bias-motivated crimes alleging that he pasted black stickers reading "Fight Terror, Nuke Israel" on the front door of a Colorado Springs Jewish center, Black said. The doors were defaced about 1:30 a.m. June 10, and detectives identified Planer from a surveillance tape, he said.

The highway patrol had recommended 68 felony charges and 514 misdemeanors. But prosecutors rejected dozens of lower-level crimes, including 85 counts of unlawful assembly, 55 counts of conspiracy to unlawfully assemble and 32 counts related to the possession of illegal signs and banners.

It took prosecutors five months to review the agency's 2,000-page report and hours of related video.

Videos posted on social media showed participants throwing stones toward a man who was holding a stick as he was protected by police officers wearing riot gear. Other videos showed officers on horseback dispersing protesters, some with their faces covered.

The highway patrol said its investigation was made more difficult because many of the counter-demonstrators were masked. Many participants were difficult to locate or refused to cooperate, the agency said.

The Traditionalist Worker Party was formed in 2015 as the political wing of the white nationalist Traditionalist Youth Network, according to The Southern Poverty Law Center, which studies extremist groups across the nation.

"We are unapologetically nationalists, fighting to secure the existence of our people and a future for White children," the party says on its website.

The group had a permit for the Capitol rally, while counter-protesters did not have a permit and were there to prevent the white nationalists' rally, the highway patrol said.

Several uninvolved observers criticized police for being too slow to break up the fighting.

Copyright © The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


Don Thompson


    Catch up on the top news and features from KSL.com, sent weekly.
    By subscribing, you acknowledge and agree to KSL.com's Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

    KSL Weather Forecast